Reviewing outcomes and benefits determines the degree of the programme’s or project’s success. These reviews are called the ‘operations review and benefits realisation’ assurance review. For some programmes and projects, a wider, more extensive formal evaluation needs to be undertaken in accordance with the Magenta Book (see Chapter 2: Policy and evaluation).
After a programme or project is closed, the sponsoring body should ensure that planned assurance reviews and evaluations are undertaken to assess the extent to which benefits realisation and operational performance are meeting, and are likely to continue to meet, the objectives and expectations stated in the business case. Such reviews also play an important part in evaluation.
Reviewing the outcome of a programme or project is the responsibility of the sponsoring body (see 13.3.2 on the sponsoring body) and includes determining, based on the latest approved business case and supporting documentation, whether:
- the planned benefits were realised
- the predicted costs were as planned
- the outcomes are a reality and are being sustained
- the operational systems, processes and structures are effective
- the solution meets the needs, both for users and citizens
- final evaluation is under way or planned (see Chapter 2: Policy and evaluation)
A final report on performance against the business case should be completed including recalculating the social costs and social benefits, drawing on the information listed above.
Lessons identified during the review should be recorded and communicated where they can be of benefit for undertaking future work or result in improved working practices (see Chapter 38: Learning from experience).
An assurance review or evaluation should be undertaken when enough time has elapsed to assess the benefits of the programme or project and the use and operation of the outputs. The review should focus primarily on outcomes and benefits, but if these fall short of business case projections, for example because a solution is faulty or circumstances have changed, the reasons for this should also be considered. This might require the former senior responsible owner, programme or project manager or relevant senior team managers to be consulted.